In "Finding Nemo," a tropical fish named Gil, grizzled
and scarred from his many attempts to escape an aquarium in the lobby of a
dentist's office, tells a newcomer to the tank: "Fish aren't meant to be
in a box, kid. It does things to ya."
The line drew laughs from the
audience at an advance screening of the latest computer-animated offering
from Walt Disney Co. and Pixar Inc.,
which opens Friday. But it's eliciting grimaces from people in the
international trade of live ocean fish, coral and other marine life, a
$200-million industry.
Pet fish importers — whose international hub
is in Southern California — worry that the story of the plucky
orange-and-white-striped clownfish, kidnapped from his home in the Great
Barrier Reef, will create a backlash against an industry already laboring
under the perception that it damages fish habitats, particularly coral
reefs.
"There is a political message," said Burton Patrick, chief
operating officer of six Pet Supplies Plus stores in the
Pittsburgh area and a former operations manager for the Detroit Zoo.
Disney "wants kids to feel sorry for something that might or might not
have a concept of mortality."
Eric Cohen, co-owner of Sea
Dwelling Creatures Inc., a Los Angeles distributor of wild-caught
marine fish and coral, wonders whether moviegoers will "walk out and say
that fish should not be separated from their friends in the
ocean."
There's no doubt that the creators of "Finding Nemo" want
children to become emotionally attached to the quirky fish characters,
said Andrew Stanton, a Pixar veteran who wrote and directed the film.
That's what moviemaking is about.
And Stanton doesn't mind if
viewers leave theaters thinking about the environment as well.
"The
random hobbyist doesn't think that taking one fish out of the ocean will
matter," said Stanton, who got the idea for the story from the "funky fish
tank in my dentist's office when I was a kid."
"I always assumed
these animals were caged and wanted to go home," he said.
The
perceived mental state of aquarium-bound fish aside, Adam Summers, a UC
Irvine marine biologist and a consultant on "Finding Nemo," said catching
sea life "for the pet trade really does have an effect on tropical fish
stocks.
"There have been terrible problems in the Philippines and
other places where there are pretty-colored fish people want for their
aquariums," he said.
Like movies, the trade in marine animals is
very much a Southern California industry. The business is dependent on the
long supply chain that starts in the coral reefs of the Pacific and Indian
oceans and leads to 104th Street near Los Angeles International Airport, a
stretch known as Fish Street and regarded as the nucleus of the world's
aquarium business.
There, about a dozen firms import live fish,
coral, shrimp, crabs and other sea creatures, which arrive by air in
foam-lined packing boxes from such places as Fiji, the Philippines and
Indonesia. The animals then are resold to pet and fish stores across North
America and Europe.
This is a sensitive time for the industry. It
has fought off proposals for federal legislation to curtail the numbers
and types of sea life that could be imported to the United States, in part
by promising to develop a policing program.
At least one nonprofit
organization is promoting an independent certification process to help
ensure that tropical fish caught in the wild are treated humanely, similar
to the dolphin-safe campaign that informs buyers of canned tuna that,
presumably, no dolphins were netted in the course of catching
tuna.
The Honolulu-based Marine Aquarium Council is in the early
stages of a program to award its stamp of approval to businesses within
the pet fish supply chain — from reef to retailer — that meet its
standards. Its goal is to eliminate harmful collection methods, such as
the use of poisonous sodium cyanide to stun wild fish, and to reduce the
mortality rate of aquarium fish during transport and storage.
The
group also is endorsing attempts to farm-raise tropical fish as a way to
avoid endangering species and their reef habitats and to keep hobbyists'
aquariums filled with eye-catching specimens. The best success story to
come from the captive breeding of tropical fish involves the clownfish,
the same species from which the star of "Finding Nemo" hails.
The
council hopes the movie will help spotlight its efforts to clean up the
industry and "alert new potential hobbyists about the good and the bad
ways that tropical fish are harvested."
The organization already
has used the film as a marketing opportunity: With the help of Cohen of
Sea Dwelling, one of the largest marine fish distributors, it set up an
aquarium of clownfish and other marine animals at the "Finding Nemo"
premiere party last Sunday.
And although the industry worries
about a backlash, some believe the opposite will happen. The film could
inspire children to nag their parents for "Nemos" of their own, sparking a
boomlet in the saltwater aquarium hobby, said John Brandt, legislative
representative for the Marine Aquarium Societies of North America, the
umbrella body for hobbyists.
Sales of Dalmatian puppies rose after
Disney's 1996 release of its live-action version of "101 Dalmatians."
Anticipating a similar reaction, Paul Holthus, executive director of the
Marine Aquarium Council, said, "It's important that this demand is met
with marine life that's been harvested from the sea or captive-bred in a
manner safe for both the fish and the environment."
Yet some fish
trade veterans doubt the Marine Aquarium Council efforts will make a
difference in the way the industry operates.
"A lot of people have
serious concerns that MAC amounts to little more than greenwashing of
business-as-usual in the aquarium trade," said John Tullock, founder of
the American Marinelife Dealers Assn. and author of "Natural Reef
Aquariums," a respected hobby manual.
Tullock, who has left the
AMDA and now objects to collecting tropical fish, sees "Finding Nemo" as
helping to make a case on the animals' behalf.
"I am pleased to
see that the issue of taking wild fish off coral reefs to decorate
dentists' offices is getting some well-deserved attention," he
said.
Although there is wide consensus that coral reef habitats are
in crisis worldwide, how much damage is inflicted by the aquarium trade is
a source of debate even among marine biologists.
"The major threats
are overfishing for food, which has destabilized whole reef systems;
global warming, which kills corals directly; and in coastal areas, [from]
pollution and sedimentation," said Gregor Hodgson, a UCLA marine ecologist
and director of the Reef Check global coral reef monitoring program. "In
comparison to these threats, the marine aquarium trade is a small
problem."
Whether "Finding Nemo" will focus attention on the
plight of coral reefs and their inhabitants remains to be seen, Hodgson
said. But as pet-store owner Mitch Gibbs of Bowling Green, Ky., put it: "
'Bambi' did not stop deer hunting."

